The frigid waters of the North Atlantic hold one of history's greatest pirate mysteries - the lost treasure of Henry Avery, worth over $100 million today. Featured on Expedition Unknown, this remote site marks where adventurer Josh Gates dove deep into treacherous waters searching for remnants of the most successful pirate's legendary 1695 heist of the Mughal treasure ship Ganj-i-Sawai. This underwater investigation site offers a glimpse into one of maritime history's most enduring unsolved mysteries.
The North Atlantic Treasure Site refers to the broad search area in international waters where Josh Gates and his team dove in pursuit of pirate Henry Avery's legendary fortune from the 1695 capture of the Ganj-i-Sawai. The coordinates lie roughly equidistant between Newfoundland and Ireland, in waters known for frigid temperatures and challenging dive conditions. Avery's haul—estimated at over $100 million in today's value—has never been recovered, making it one of history's greatest unsolved treasure mysteries. Gates' investigation focused on searching the seafloor for evidence of Avery's fleet or scattered cargo from the pirate's final voyage.
Henry Avery captures the Mughal treasure ship Ganj-i-Sawai in one of history's most lucrative pirate raids
Avery disappears from historical record, last rumored sightings place him sailing toward the North Atlantic
Modern treasure hunters and researchers narrow search zones using historical shipping routes and ocean current modeling
Henry Avery remains one of the most elusive figures in pirate history. After seizing the Ganj-i-Sawai—a Mughal Empire treasure ship carrying gold, silver, and jewels belonging to the Emperor's family—Avery vanished so completely that historians debate whether he died wealthy in hiding or penniless under an assumed name. Mainstream historians note that no confirmed trace of Avery's treasure has ever surfaced, despite centuries of speculation and numerous searches.
The North Atlantic search zone represents one theory among several about Avery's final movements. Some maritime historians believe Avery sailed toward the British Isles or Ireland, where he might have had contacts to fence the stolen goods. Others argue he headed to the Caribbean or even back to the Indian Ocean. Without definitive ship logs or wreckage, the search remains speculative, guided more by historical shipping routes and ocean drift patterns than hard evidence.
Gates' investigation brought modern technology to this centuries-old mystery, but the North Atlantic's vastness and depth make any search enormously challenging. The episode explored the difficulties of pinpointing wreck sites in international waters with limited historical documentation. Even with sonar scanning and dive teams, the investigation highlighted how many pirate treasure legends remain just that—legends, tantalizing but unproven.
What makes Avery's case particularly compelling is that, unlike many pirate myths, the treasure itself is historically verified. The Ganj-i-Sawai robbery is documented in Mughal records and triggered an international manhunt. The fortune existed; where it ended up remains one of maritime history's enduring questions.
Henry Avery's raid on the Ganj-i-Sawai so enraged Mughal Emperor Aurangzeb that it nearly destroyed the British East India Company's trading privileges in India.
Avery's treasure haul in 1695 was estimated at over £600,000—roughly equivalent to $100-130 million today, making it one of the largest pirate scores in history.
Avery is believed to be one of the only major pirates of the Golden Age who successfully retired with his fortune rather than being captured or killed.
The North Atlantic search area encompasses some of the same waters where Titanic sank in 1912, roughly 400 miles southeast of Newfoundland.
As an international waters location without fixed infrastructure, this site is not accessible to general visitors. Specialized ocean research or treasure-hunting expeditions require significant maritime experience, cold-water diving certification, and vessel support. Any exploration in this region should account for North Atlantic weather patterns and international maritime law.
St. John's, Newfoundland, Canada, approximately 800-900 miles to the west, depending on exact search coordinates.
If conducting maritime research, summer months (June through August) offer relatively calmer seas and warmer surface temperatures, though North Atlantic conditions remain challenging year-round.
Bahamas - Maravillas Wreck Site
Another Gates investigation of sunken treasure from historical maritime robberies, involving similar deep-water search techniques.
Caribbean
Historical pirate activity zone where Avery and other Golden Age pirates operated before and after major raids.
Florida Waters
Gates has investigated multiple shipwreck and treasure sites in Florida waters, applying comparable underwater search methodologies.
Best time to visit: Summer months (June-August) offer the calmest seas and best visibility for any maritime activities in these challenging North Atlantic waters.
Travel tip: This is an extremely remote deep-water location accessible only by specialized research vessels - consider joining organized maritime archaeology expeditions or historical cruises that visit North Atlantic wreck sites.
No episodes mapped yet.